Cal/OSHA is working on new rules that would crack down and step up enforcement and penalties against California employers that commit “egregious” and “enterprise-wide” workplace safety violations.
The forthcoming rules would impose substantial penalties on companies that have shown a disregard towards California workplace safety regulations and the wellbeing of their employees. Employers that are cited for egregious violations could be fined up to $158,000 “per instance,” meaning it can be applied for each employee exposed to the violation. And there’s more.
As well, businesses with multiple locations will have to be especially mindful of complying with Cal/OSHA regulations to ensure they are not snared for the same violations at two or more locations.
The new rules implement a 2021 law, SB 606, and will bring Cal/OSHA’s rules in line with Fed-OSHA’s as federal law requires that state-run OSHA enforcement programs to be “at least as effective” as the federal program.
Here’s what’s on tap:
Enterprise-wide violation
Under the proposed rules, a violation is enterprise-wide if an employer has multiple worksites and either of the following is true:
- The employer has a written policy or procedure that violates occupational safety and health regulations; or
- The Division of Occupational Safety and Health has evidence of a pattern or practice of the same violation or violations involving more than one of the employer’s worksites.
The proposed penalty for enterprise-wide violations is multiplied by the number of worksites covered at inspection, up to a maximum of $158,727 per exposed worker, and will be adjusted each year for inflation.
If an employer fails to abate violations noted by a Cal/OSHA inspector at any worksite covered by the citation in a timely manner, a separate “failure to abate” penalty of up to $15,000 may be assessed for each instance.
Egregious violation
The proposed rules define an egregious violation as a willful violation where the employer has had a previous egregious violation in the past five years. One or more of the following apply:
- The employer, intentionally, through conscious, voluntary action or inaction, made no reasonable effort to eliminate the known violation.
- The employer has a history of one or more serious, repeat or willful violations or more than 20 general or regulatory violations per 100 employees.
- The employer intentionally disregarded its health and safety responsibilities, such as by failing to maintain an effective Injury and Illness Program, ignoring safety and health hazards, or refusing to comply with the Cal/OSHA Act.
- The employer’s conduct, taken as a whole, amounts to clear bad faith in the performance of their duties to comply with occupational safety and health standards.
- Within the five years preceding a citation for an egregious violation, the employer has committed more than five violations of any Title 8 standard that has become finalized.
- The violations resulted in worker fatalities, a worksite catastrophe, or five or more injuries or illnesses. Catastrophe is defined as inpatient hospitalization of three or more workers from a workplace hazard.
- Within the 12 months immediately preceding the underlying violation, 10% of all employees at the cited worksite sustained workplace injuries or illnesses.
According to the Cal-OSHA Reporter newsletter, it’s expected that the proposed maximum penalty for egregious violations will be $158,727, adjusted each year according to the consumer price index. Importantly, each employee that is exposed to an egregious violation would be considered a separate violation. Since the penalty can be assessed on a per-instance basis, it could quickly spiral for some employers.
The takeaway
The proposed regulations pose the largest risk for companies with multiple locations.
Employers should double down on their workplace safety efforts and ensure that there is buy-in to the program from top management down to supervisors and line workers at all locations.